Ganhe Rápido nos Jogos Populares do Cassino Online 580bet Cassino bet 7k: Diversão e Grandes Vitórias Esperam por Você Aposte e Vença no Cassino leao – Jogos Fáceis e Populares Jogos Populares e Grandes Prêmios no Cassino Online luck 2 Descubra os Jogos Mais Populares no Cassino john bet e Ganhe 7755 bet: Apostas Fáceis, Grandes Oportunidades de Vitória Jogue no Cassino Online cbet e Aumente suas Chances de Ganhar Ganhe Prêmios Incríveis com Jogos Populares no Cassino bet7 Cassino pk55: Onde a Sorte Está ao Seu Lado Experimente o Cassino 8800 bet e Ganhe com Jogos Populares Ganhe Facilmente no Cassino Online doce Aposte e Vença no Cassino bet 4 Jogos Populares e Grandes Premiações na f12bet Descubra a Diversão e Vitória no Cassino bet7 Aposte nos Jogos Mais Populares do Cassino ggbet Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos no Cassino Online bet77 Jogos Fáceis e Rápidos no Cassino mrbet Jogue e Ganhe com Facilidade no Cassino bet61 Cassino tvbet: Onde a Sorte Está Ao Seu Lado Aposte nos Melhores Jogos do Cassino Online pgwin Ganhe Grande no Cassino today com Jogos Populares Cassino fuwin: Grandes Vitórias Esperam por Você Experimente os Melhores Jogos no Cassino brwin Jogue e Ganhe no Cassino bet7k – Simples e Rápido Cassino tv bet: Vença com Jogos Populares e Simples Ganhe no Cassino Online allwin com Facilidade Aposte nos Jogos Mais Famosos no Cassino stake bwin 789: Aposta Fácil, Vitória Garantida Descubra os Jogos Populares do Cassino lvbet e Vença Jogue no Cassino blaze e Ganhe Grandes Prêmios Cassino dj bet: Simples, Divertido e Lucrativo Aposte e Ganhe no Cassino umbet – Diversão Garantida Ganhe Rápido nos Jogos do Cassino Online b1bet 20bet: Jogue e Ganhe com Facilidade e Diversão Cassino bk bet: Entre Agora e Ganhe Grandes Prêmios Jogue no Cassino h2bet e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias Ganhe no Cassino 7kbet com Jogos Populares e Fáceis Aposte e Conquiste Prêmios no Cassino Online fbbet Diversão e Prêmios Fáceis no Cassino 9d bet Cassino Online 9k bet: Jogos Populares, Grandes Oportunidades Jogue no Cassino 73 bet e Aumente Suas Chances de Vitória Cassino ktobet: Onde Você Pode Ganhar Facilmente Ganhe Rápido com os Jogos Populares do Cassino 74 bet Aposte nos Melhores Jogos e Ganhe no Cassino betpix betvip: Onde a Sorte Encontra os Melhores Jogadores Jogue no Cassino batbet e Ganhe Prêmios Instantâneos Ganhe Agora nos Jogos do Cassino Online onabet Cassino f12bet: Diversão e Vitórias Esperam por Você Aposte Agora no Cassino codbet e Ganhe com Facilidade Jogos Populares do Cassino winbra para Você Ganhar Ganhe Grande com os Jogos Mais Populares no b2xbet Cassino obabet: Jogue Agora e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias Experimente a Diversão e Ganhe no Cassino Online brlwin Jogue nos Melhores Jogos e Vença no Cassino onebra Ganhe Prêmios Fáceis e Rápidos no Cassino winbrl Aposte nos Jogos Populares do Cassino omgbet e Ganhe Cassino queens: Grandes Oportunidades de Vitória Ganhe Facilmente com os Jogos do Cassino Online brdice brapub: Aposte Agora e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias Aposte e Ganhe com Facilidade no Cassino Online flames Ganhe Dinheiro Fácil nos Jogos do Cassino betano Cassino aajogo: Jogos Populares e Grandes Prêmios Jogue e Vença no Cassino iribet – Onde a Sorte Está Aposte no Cassino pixbet e Ganhe Prêmios Fantásticos Ganhe Grande nos Jogos Populares do Cassino betsul Cassino Online fezbet: Onde Você Sempre Pode Ganhar Aposte nos Melhores Jogos e Ganhe no Cassino curso beta betway: Jogue e Ganhe Agora com Facilidade Experimente o Cassino Online bkbet e Ganhe Rápido Ganhe Dinheiro Jogando nos Jogos Populares do Cassino peixe beta Jogue no Cassino bet365 e Ganhe de Forma Simples e Rápida Ganhe No Cassino pixbet: Jogos Populares, Grandes Prêmios Aposte Agora e Conquiste Vitórias no Cassino 4 play bet Ganhe no Cassino Online 365bet: Diversão e Vitória Cassino brxbet: Aposte com Facilidade e Ganhe Prêmios Aposte no Cassino 939 bet e Vença Agora Mesmo Cassino seubet: Ganhe Jogando os Melhores Jogos Jogue no Cassino Online cnc bet e Aumente Suas Chances Ganhe com Facilidade nos Jogos Populares do gbg bet Jogue e Vença no Cassino 522bet – O Melhor para Você Cassino Online brl bet: Apostas Fáceis, Grandes Vitórias Ganhe com Facilidade no Cassino Online pagbet Aposte no Cassino jonbet e Experimente a Diversão jqk bet: Jogue e Ganhe com Prêmios Instantâneos Ganhe Dinheiro Fácil nos Jogos do Cassino 166bet Cassino Online abc bet: Onde os Jogos Populares Levam à Vitória Aposte e Ganhe Agora nos Jogos do Cassino bggbet Jogos Populares e Grandes Oportunidades de Vitória na obabet Cassino 136bet: Onde Você Pode Ganhar Rápido e Fácil Ganhe Agora nos Jogos Populares do Cassino mmabet Aposte Agora no Cassino win bet e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias Jogue nos Jogos Mais Populares e Ganhe no Cassino ir6 bet Cassino 667bet: Jogue e Conquiste Vitórias Rápidas Ganhe no Cassino Online qqq bet com Jogos Simples e Populares 193 bet: Apostas Fáceis, Grandes Chances de Ganhar Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos e Simples no Cassino dobrowin Aposte nos Melhores Jogos e Vença no Cassino betleao Jogue e Ganhe no Cassino moverbet com Facilidade Ganhe Agora no Cassino Online winzada 777 com Jogos Populares supremo: Apostas Fáceis e Grandes Vitórias Aposte nos Jogos Populares do Cassino casadeapostas e Vença Cassino dobrowin: Grandes Premiações com Jogos Fáceis Ganhe no Cassino betleao com Jogos Populares e Simples Jogue e Vença Agora no Cassino moverbet wazamba: Aposte e Ganhe Grande nos Jogos Populares Cassino Online fezbet: Simples, Divertido e Lucrativo Ganhe Agora nos Jogos Populares do Cassino betsson Aposte e Vença no Cassino lvbet – Jogue e Ganhe dobrowin: Onde Você Joga e Ganha Com Facilidade Ganhe Rápido e Fácil no Cassino Online betsul Ganhe Fácil no Cassino Online pixbet Aposte e Vença com Jogos Populares no bwin Jogos Fáceis, Grandes Vitórias no Cassino betobet dobrowin: Apostas Simples, Grandes Premiações Ganhe Agora nos Jogos Populares do Cassino bet7 Aposte nos Melhores Jogos e Ganhe no Cassino betcris Jogue e Conquiste Grandes Prêmios no blaze Ganhe Rápido com Jogos Populares no Cassino 888 Cassino betano: O Melhor Lugar para Apostar e Ganhar Jogue Agora e Ganhe no Cassino Online stake stake: Onde a Sorte Encontra os Melhores Jogadores Ganhe Facilmente com os Jogos do Cassino esportesdasorte Aposte e Vença no Cassino Online betmotion Jogue nos Jogos Populares e Ganhe no rivalry Aposte no novibet e Ganhe Grandes Prêmios Cassino pinnacle: Grandes Vitórias com Jogos Populares Ganhe Agora com os Jogos do Cassino cbet Aposte e Conquiste Vitórias no dobrowin betleao: Onde Grandes Vitórias São Fáceis de Alcançar Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos no Cassino moverbet Jogos Populares e Grandes Oportunidades no Cassino gogowin jogos win: Vença com Jogos Populares e Rápidos Aposte no Cassino campobet e Ganhe Grande Ganhe Facilmente com os Jogos do Cassino mesk bet Cassino infinity bet: Onde Jogadores Conquistam Prêmios Jogue Agora no Cassino betfury e Ganhe Facilmente Aposte com Facilidade e Ganhe no doce Ganhe Jogando os Melhores Jogos no bet7k Jogue e Vença no Cassino Online jogowin lobo888: Aposte Agora e Ganhe Grandes Vitórias Ganhe Agora no Cassino iribet com Facilidade Jogue e Conquiste Prêmios no Cassino Online leao dobrowin: Onde a Sorte Está ao Seu Lado Aposte e Ganhe Grandes Prêmios no allwin Ganhe Grandes Prêmios Jogando no aajogo Jogos Populares e Grandes Oportunidades no pgwin Ganhe Fácil com os Jogos Populares do Cassino greenbets Aposte no brapub e Vença com Jogos Populares Cassino moverbet: Aposte Agora e Ganhe Facilmente Ganhe Agora com os Jogos Populares do onebra Jogue e Vença Agora no Cassino flames Ganhe Rápido com os Jogos do Cassino brdice brwin: Jogos Populares e Grandes Vitórias Aposte nos Jogos Populares e Ganhe no poplottery queens: Grandes Prêmios Esperam por Você Jogue Agora no winbrl e Ganhe Fácil Aposte e Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos no Cassino omgbet Ganhe no winbra com Jogos Populares e Simples Aposte e Ganhe no Cassino goinbet Agora Jogue Agora e Ganhe no codbet com Facilidade betleao: Onde a Sorte Se Encontra com Você Ganhe Rápido e Fácil no Cassino fuwin allwin568: Aposte Agora e Ganhe com Facilidade Ganhe Grande no Cassino wingdus Aposte no juntosbet e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias today: Onde Jogadores Ganham com Facilidade Jogue no talon777 e Ganhe com Simplicidade Ganhe Agora no Cassino Online brlwin com Facilidade Aposte e Vença no fazobetai – O Cassino dos Vencedores pinup bet: Ganhe Rápido com os Melhores Jogos Aposte nos Melhores Jogos no bet sport e Ganhe Ganhe no bet esporte com Jogos Fáceis e Populares mrbet: O Cassino Online Onde Você Ganha Fácil Ganhe no Cassino premier bet com Jogos Populares e Fáceis Jogue e Vença no Cassino apostebet Agora Aposte e Ganhe no spicy bet com Jogos Fáceis Ganhe no prosport bet com Jogos Simples e Populares Aposte e Conquiste Grandes Vitórias no bet nacional Jogue Agora no luck e Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos jogodeouro: Apostas Fáceis e Grandes Oportunidades de Vitória Ganhe no heads bet com Facilidade nos Jogos Populares Aposte no marjack bet e Ganhe Agora com Facilidade Jogue no apostaganha e Ganhe Prêmios Instantâneos gbg bet: Onde Você Sempre Ganha Ganhe Fácil no Cassino esoccer bet com Jogos Populares Aposte e Ganhe Grande no Cassino Online esport bet Ganhe Agora com Jogos Populares no realbet Jogue no aposte e ganhe e Conquiste Vitórias Rápidas aviator aposta: Apostas Fáceis, Prêmios Incríveis Ganhe no bet vitoria com Facilidade e Diversão Aposte e Ganhe no imperador bet – Apostas Populares Jogue no realsbet e Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos e Fáceis Ganhe Agora com os Jogos do Cassino bet favorita Cassino esportenet: Grandes Vitórias Esperam por Você Aposte no flames bet e Conquiste Grandes Prêmios Ganhe Fácil no pague bet com Jogos Populares Jogue Agora no betsury e Ganhe Grande doce888: Onde Você Joga e Ganha com Facilidade Ganhe Grande no Cassino obabet Agora Jogue no winzada e Ganhe Prêmios Fantásticos Aposte e Ganhe no Cassino globalbet – O Melhor Lugar bet77: Onde Jogos Populares Levam à Vitória Ganhe Rápido com os Jogos do Cassino Online lottoland Aposte e Vença Agora no 7gamesbet Jogue no dicasbet e Conquiste Vitórias Fáceis Ganhe Agora com os Jogos do Cassino esportivabet Aposte no tvbet e Ganhe Rápido sportbet: Apostas Fáceis com Grandes Resultados Ganhe Grande no Cassino misterjackbet com Jogos Populares Jogue no Cassino esportebet e Ganhe de Forma Simples e Rápida Ganhe Rápido no Cassino Online nacionalbet Aposte e Vença no simplesbet com Jogos Populares betestrela: Cassino Online Fácil de Jogar e Ganhar Jogos Populares, Grandes Premiações no batbet Ganhe Fácil no Pk55 – O Cassino Online dos Vencedores Aposte e Conquiste Vitórias no Cassino Bet61 Upsports Bet: Diversão e Grandes Ganhos com Jogos Populares Ganhe Agora no roleta online com Jogos Simples e Populares Jogue no roleta e Vença com Facilidade Cassino Online poker online: Onde Você Pode Ganhar Agora poker: Onde Jogadores Conquistam Grandes Vitórias Ganhe Fácil no Cassino Online blackjack online com Jogos Populares Aposte no bingo e Ganhe Rápido com Jogos Famosos Ceará: Apostas Rápidas, Vitórias Imediatas Ganhe Prêmios Fantásticos com Jogos Populares no Paysandu Juventude: O Melhor Cassino Online para Ganhar Jogue e Vença no Cassino Online Bahia com Facilidade Sport: Grandes Oportunidades de Ganhar nos Jogos Populares Aposte no Cassino Cuiabá e Conquiste Grandes Prêmios Ganhe Rápido no Coritiba – Apostas Fáceis, Grandes Prêmios Jogos Fáceis e Grandes Vitórias no Criciúma Aposte no Vitória e Ganhe Com Facilidade nos Jogos Populares Fortaleza: Onde a Sorte Está ao Seu Lado Ganhe no Corinthians – Simples, Rápido e Divertido Jogue Agora e Vença no Cassino São Paulo Ganhe Agora no Cassino Online Vasco com Jogos Populares Aposte e Ganhe no Cassino Online Grêmio Fluminense: Onde Você Joga e Ganha com Facilidade Ganhe no Cassino Cruzeiro com Jogos Populares e Fáceis Botafogo: Ganhe Rápido com Jogos Populares Cassino Flamengo: Vença Agora com Facilidade Ganhe Agora com Jogos Populares no Cassino bingo slots slots slots: Cassino Online Rápido e Simples de Ganhar Aposte nos Jogos Populares e Ganhe no Cassino hacker do slot pg slot demo: O Cassino Online Mais Fácil de Ganhar Jogue e Vença Agora no slot win – Cassino Online Fácil pg slot soft: Ganhe Grandes Prêmios com Jogos Fáceis Cassino arne slot: Onde Você Pode Ganhar com Facilidade Aposte Agora e Vença no Cassino Online riqueza slots slots 777: Jogos Populares, Grandes Vitórias Ganhe Agora no pg slot com Facilidade nos Jogos Populares Jogue e Ganhe no 777 slot game com Apostas Simples slot pg soft: Aposte Agora e Ganhe Rápido Aposte e Vença nos Jogos Populares do Cassino hacker slot Ganhe no 777 slots – Diversão e Grandes Prêmios Jogue e Conquiste Vitórias no slot-pg-soft com Facilidade Ganhe Prêmios Fáceis no Cassino Online fortune ox demo grátis demo fortune ox: Apostas Fáceis e Grandes Oportunidades Jogue no fortune mouse demo e Ganhe com Facilidade nos Jogos Populares fortune ox demo: Onde a Sorte Está ao Seu Lado para Ganhar Ganhe Grande no Cassino jogo fortune tiger com Jogos Populares Cassino Online fortune tiger grátis: Ganhe Fácil e Rápido Jogue Agora e Ganhe Prêmios Rápidos no fortune tiger baixar fortune tiger demo grátis: O Cassino Mais Fácil para Ganhar Aposte e Ganhe Rápido com Jogos Populares no fortune tiger demo Ganhe Fácil no fortune tiger 777 com Jogos Simples e Rápidos!
Uzbekistan’s Pivot to Regional Engagement

Uzbekistan’s Pivot to Regional Engagement


Nowhere is Uzbekistan's constant juggling act between advancing national security interests and producing much-needed economic growth so readily apparent as at its long Ferghana Valley border. Foreign policy under the authoritarian former president of Uzbekistan, Islam Karimov, often seemed to prefer economic and political isolation over collaboration with regional neighbors, resulting in miles of mined borders and simmering tensions. Thus, it was quite the surprise when newly-minted Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoyev declared to the UN in 2017 that he would be re-orienting Uzbekistan’s foreign policy to better create “a zone of stability, sustainable development, and good-neighborliness” in the region.

This announcement has given rise to a series of previously unthinkable treaties and agreements with Uzbekistan’s neighbors, primarily aimed at addressing the numerous issues surrounding Uzbekistan’s borders with Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan. Some of these agreements will undoubtedly lead to the betterment of citizens’ lives in the area, but how high should hopes be for the “reset” of these borders? A careful analysis suggests that it is too soon for Mirziyoyev’s government to back up its lofty statements; economic imperatives are driving positive changes at the border, but the political and security realities of the country will prevent a true opening of borders and free movement of peoples of which the Uzbek president has hinted.

The sad history of Uzbekistan’s Ferghana border was born out of the chaos following the declaration of independence from the USSR in 1991. Many books have been written on the drawing of the often-arbitrary borders separating the five Soviet Central Asian republics, and it is perhaps no surprise that Uzbek authorities did not initially show a strong interest in stationing troops at their new international borders. Tajik citizen Sonya Satarova put it best in an interview with BBC Russia, recalling that, “the borders were open back then, nobody could have imagined that there would come a time when we can’t see each other whenever we want.” The border would remain loosely-manned and highly permeable through the mid-1990s.

This dynamic changed for the worse in late 1998 and early 1999. Bridges were destroyed, transport lines cut, and scores of border crossing points shut. Uzbek leaders publicly articulated the crackdown as a measure to protect against terrorism. In 1999, a series of bombings rocked Tashkent, and President Karimov blamed his political and personal enemies, the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan.

Alternatively, this radical change in border policy can also be attributed to local political and economic interests. Informal shuttle trade across a permeable border was a potential drain of hard currency that the regime was intent on retaining, as well as a threat to nascent domestic production and trade. Uzbekistan was determined to weather the economic storm that overtook the region after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, and leaders prioritized strong state control of the economy over the potentially destabilizing effects of foreign markets.

Finally, as academics Megoran, Raballand, and Boyjou point out, the creation of “the border” as a concept was crucial to Karimov’s nationalization efforts. Forging an Uzbekistan that is both simultaneously strong yet also threatened by external enemies was an active priority of the government, with a lot of public discourse directed towards demonizing the new neighbors in the valley. Karimov’s public statement in 1999, that “Kyrgyzstan is a poor country, and it is not my job to look after the people,” perfectly illustrates this new paradigm. Even more indicative of this strong vs. weak dichotomy was the decision to seal Ferghana Valley borders literally days after the Tashkent bombings.

As these borders hardened, they became the fronts of cold and occasionally hot conflicts. Uzbek involvement in the Tajik Civil War in support of the opponents of eventual Tajik President Rahmon Emomali began a cycle of antipathy that would lead to both governments eventually installing mines along their shared border. The ill-defined border with Kyrgyzstan similarly proved problematic. Uzbekistan’s preoccupation with domestic terror led to operatives kidnapping opposition leaders off Kyrgyz sovereign territory, as well as targeting the terrorist groups that Uzbek authorities claimed were infiltrating from the relatively-lax Kyrgyz borders. Both countries have even gone as far as passing legislation creating volunteer militias to assist in monitoring the border.

It is within the context of these tense border situations that the recent developments associated with Shavkat Mirziyoyev’s young presidency have seemed so groundbreaking. On September 5, 2017, the presidents of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan signed documents demarcating 1170 kilometers of the border, around 80% of the total. Both sides additionally pledged to continue working on the remaining disputed sections, as well as indicating that they hope to increase bilateral trade to over $500 million. Crucially, the long-restricted Do’stlik/Dostuk border crossing between Uzbek Andijan and Kyrgyz Osh was finally re-opened. In a statement that would have sounded absurd even a couple of years ago, Mirziyoyev stated that “we will turn our border into a border of friendship.”

The story has been similarly positive between Uzbekistan and Tajikistan, with the lower house of the Tajik Parliament ratifying an agreement on March 19, 2018 to introduce a visa-free program that will allow for stays of up to 30 days for citizens of the two countries. Ten new border crossing points have been opened, up from a previous two continuously-operating international border crossing points. Agreements were similarly reached to have the border completely de-mined by 2019, and to demarcate a large portion of it.

On a purely human level, these agreements have been monumental. With ethnic Uzbeks making up around 15% of Kyrgyzstan’s population and ethnic Tajiks accounting for as much of 30% of Uzbekistan’s population, over the past twenty years cross-border family relationships have been severely restricted as a result of the closed borders. Known to locals as “telegrams,” permits to cross the border were previously almost impossible to obtain. Now, a passport from either country is all that is needed to cross the Kyrgyz-Uzbek border, while the Tajik-Uzbek 30-day stay is similarly game-changing for visiting relatives.

Cross-border trade has been a key aspect of this border reset, with the closed border previously strangling economic opportunities for communities on either side of the border. Visa costs and costs of transportation through treacherous mountain passes had previously decreased the viability of cross-border trade. Now, however, according to Kyrgyz border officials, up to 18,000 people were crossing the Dostuk BCP daily in June 2018.

The re-opening of access to local bazaars will hopefully stimulate trade. But it remains to be seen if Kyrgyzstan’s membership in the Eurasian Economic Union will significantly hurt the important re-export of goods from China in regional bazaars (accounting for almost $2 billion of trade in 2006). Even more promising is the 2017 Uzbek legislation “On Measures to Further Streamline the Foreign Economic Activity of the Republic of Uzbekistan” that lowered custom duties on more than 8,000 imported goods, with the average customs rate reduced to around 6.45%.

While it is tempting to be swept up in the euphoria of a moment that seems to represent a regional “end of history,” the speed and breadth of these developments should come with significant caveats. As many Central Asia watchers have pointed out, this opening up of Uzbekistan seems to be primarily oriented towards immediate economic relief of a moribund and dysfunctional public and private sector. Uzbek attitudes towards security, economics, and politics cannot be ignored, and need to be considered when analyzing the future of this reset.

While the low-hanging fruit of border demarcation has already been agreed upon by lawmakers from both Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan, the remaining thorny 15% of the border (including enclaves) has been kicked down the road for further consideration. These areas have been subject to extreme tensions, and the arithmetic of aging populations combined with a lack of access to resources and economic opportunities means that these areas are still ticking time bombs that could erupt at any second. While lack of political will on the part of the Karimov government had resulted in the lack of general progress on border demarcation, the actual sticking points on the border are still subject to the relentless logic of security dilemmas and geopolitics.

President Mirziyoyev addressed these concerns with the stunning comment, “We should not have borders [with Kyrgyzstan] and we should go forward on a completely different level.” Unfortunately, there are few viable alternatives. Straight land swaps are unlikely to work in such a populated area, and it is notoriously difficult to create reliable land corridors that do not negatively impact other transportation routes. An exchange of exclave for exclave is not particularly workable, as there is a large imbalance in population (50,000 Uzbeks in the Sokh exclave, and about 75 Kyrgyz citizens living in the Barak exclave).

The situation regarding terrorist attacks originating beyond the borders of Uzbekistan remains grim. It would be a stretch to stay that Kyrgyzstan has improved its capability to prevent infiltration by international criminal or terrorist organizations, which has been a long-standing complaint of the Uzbek government. Similarly, the recent killing of tourists in Tajikistan points to active terrorist organizations in the area, while Uzbek and Kyrgyz citizens continue to supply large numbers of fighters for international terrorist organizations such as ISIS. The liberalization of borders seems to invite the instability and cross border threats that the original closing of borders was designed to prevent. Thus, we are left with two options: either the Uzbek government is desperate enough to open its borders to the instability that it has long feared, or publicly-articulated fears of terrorism were meant to function more as an ideological function than a tactical one.

While the heightened security risks entailed by the former could weigh heavily on the country, the latter scenario is perhaps even more dangerous for Uzbekistan. As articulated by scholars like Joseph Nevins in his study of the Clinton-era “Operation Gatekeeper” border operation, the militarization of a border is a powerful tool for increasing the perceived strength of a government. In a period when Uzbekistan seems to be intent on fostering economic reform while not losing control of its long-suffering population, the erosion of an important ideological institution like the border can negatively impact the perceived control of the state. It remains to be seen how far President Mirziyoyev will push his economic agenda if it appears to endanger the social status quo.

Indeed, the militarized legacy of the border continues to claim victims. The tragic case of Farhad Myrzakulov illustrates a continued aggressive atmosphere at the border, despite the raft of positive rhetoric on the legislative level. Upon allegedly trying to illegally cross the border back into Kyrgyzstan after visiting an aunt on April 7, 2018, the 34-year-old was shot in the heart by Uzbek border guards. While both Kyrgyz and Uzbek border forces agreed to commit to better communication, it does not inspire confidence in the narrative of a border that is simply falling away.

While the movement of peoples across more open borders is likely to facilitate connections between close but long-isolated populations, it will also allow for larger scale movement of economic migrants. Tajikistan has more than 1.5 million of its citizensworking in Russia, and Uzbekistan has been one of the historical land routes for guest workers to reach Russia. This movement will only increase as the visa regime eases between the two countries, but the Uzbek government is unlikely to tolerate a larger influx of potentially disruptive migrant workers.

Finally, there is the basic question of whether border liberalization will continue at its current pace. As we discussed earlier, the movement of goods from Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan can represent a threat to Uzbek domestic producers. In the case of Kyrgyzstan, the loss of Chinese re-export business after entering the Eurasian Economic Union has led to an attempt to boost domestic production, with the net result that Kyrgyz businesses are looking to Uzbekistan as a new market. This represents a threat to a traditionally protectionist country like Uzbekistan, which is attempting to jump-start its own production.

On July 1, 2018, Uzbekistan brought new restrictions into effect that limited day laborers to bringing in a single good per month for “personal use” along the Kyrgyz border. This has dramatically impacted the shuttle trade, with the daily amount of people crossing daily at Dostuk being cut in half, down to under 9,000. This is not a sign of a whole-hearted embrace of free trade, but a continual process involving stop-start movements towards using trade with neighboring countries to kick-start a moribund economy.

The border is the first and last manifestation of a state’s power, and Central Asia has seen more than its fair share of conflicts erupt between these manifestations. As Nick Megoran illustrates, there is no such thing as a good or bad border. These invisible lines in the ground will act as states’ tools for advancing aims and achieving goals. This is a particularly useful truth to have in mind when examining the Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan and Tajikistan-Uzbekistan borders.

It seems that the “reset” of the Uzbek border with Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan is unlikely to bear the geopolitical fruit that public figures have been articulating. Positive changes like reopening checkpoints and easing visa requirements will certainly please inhabitants of the border-adjacent regions, but it is unclear how exactly this will lead to a long-term lessening of tensions in a disadvantaged and unpredictable region. The holy grail of regional cooperation – national borders and free movement of peoples – will never be achieved as long as factors like geopolitical jockeying and international terrorism go unaddressed. It remains to be seen whether border regulation will have a positive or negative net influence on the volatile Fergana Valley. While many statements and actions emanating from Tashkent have been positive in nature, experts would do well to keep expectations low and remain focused on the ever-present economic and political realities.

About the Author

Austen Dowell is an intern with ERA Institute’s Central Asia Watch Project. 


This article is produced by the Eurasian Research and Analysis Institute, Inc. (ERA Institute), a public, 501(c)(3) nonprofit institution devoted to studying Eurasian affairs. All views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).


69vnphim sex sexj88vn6969vn 123b5679 123b j88